Deaf Utopia
by Nyle DiMarco

Published: 2022

Genre(s): Celebrity Memoir, LGBTQ+, Disability

TLDR: The ANTM and DWTS alum lets us in on his childhood, raucous teen and college years, the process of grappling with his sexual identity, and brings us behind the camera all while shining a spotlight on the beauty of Deaf culture and identity.

Rating: 5 out of 5.

From the publisher

A heartfelt and inspiring memoir and Deaf culture anthem by Nyle DiMarco, actor, producer, two-time reality show winner, and cultural icon of the international Deaf community.

Before becoming the actor, producer, advocate, and model that people know today, Nyle DiMarco was half of a pair of Deaf twins born to a multi-generational Deaf family in Queens, New York. At the hospital one day after he was born, Nyle “failed” his first test—a hearing test—to the joy and excitement of his parents.

In this moving and engrossing memoir, Nyle shares stories, both heartbreaking and humorous, of what it means to navigate a world built for hearing people. From growing up in a rough-and-tumble childhood in Queens with his big and loving Italian-American family to where he is now, Nyle has always been driven to explore beyond the boundaries given him.

A college math major and athlete at Gallaudet—the famed university for the Deaf in Washington, DC—Nyle was drawn as a young man to acting, and dove headfirst into the reality show competitions America’s Next Top Model and Dancing with the Stars—ultimately winning both competitions.

Deaf Utopia is more than a memoir, it is a cultural anthem—a proud and defiant song of Deaf culture and a love letter to American Sign Language, Nyle’s primary language. Through his stories and those of his Deaf brothers, parents, and grandparents, Nyle opens many windows into the Deaf experience.

Deaf Utopia is intimate, suspenseful, hilarious, eye-opening, and smart—both a memoir and a celebration of what makes Deaf culture unique and beautiful.


My Review

I am ashamed to admit that although I watched Nyle’s season of ANTM, I had not truly taken the time to learn more about Deaf culture until I picked up this memoir. And that’s on me. It should not have taken me this long.

I loved learning more about Deaf schools, the fight the community has had to wage against audist learning models, and their winning protests for teachers and leaders that actually come from the community they are positioned to guide into the future. His anecdotes of teenage rowdiness are perfect in their universality but also perfect in their specificity – no hearing kid with hearing parents would think to simply block the light under their mom’s bedroom door and then proceed to throw a full-on party in the kitchen! What an amazing story!

The innovation and problem-solving when faced with a world not built for Deaf people that’s on display throughout this book is inspiring, but it also shouldn’t have to be that way. That, juxtaposed with the moments of isolation and disconnection due to communication barriers and lack of accommodation is a challenge to the world to consider accessibility and empathy in our day to day lives. And I, for one, am inspired to rise up and meet that challenge.


Leave a comment

Heyo! I’m so glad you’re here! I’m Lydia and welcome to my ramblings about my love of all things books and reading. I’m a millennial book blogger living in Chicago but originally from the Great State of Maine. In addition to reading (duh) I also love to cook, rock out at karaoke or take in a good musical or opera.

Rating System:

5 stars: Excellent, loved it, couldn’t put it down. Will be recommending it to all my friends and also strangers who didn’t even ask and may not have even said hello. This is my new personality now.

4 stars: Great. I loved it. I had an excellent time reading it. There’s just something that’s keeping it from absolute perfection.

3 stars: It was a good read, but it wasn’t great. I may still recommend, but only for certain people if I already know you like similar things or only with a caveat or two.

2 stars: I mean, it was a book and I finished it, I guess? Somebody must have liked it because it got published?

1 star: I have never in my life given a book a one star review. If it’s this bad, I’ll just DNF.